Parshas Toldos 5774

‘Parsha Growth Spurts’[1]

Rabbi Dani Staum

Parshas Toldos 5774

“And these are the offspring of Yitchok the son of Avrohom; Avrohom begot Yitzchok.” (Bereishis 25:19)

The Torah stresses the fact that Avrohom and Yitzchok were father and son. Rashi explains that the cynics of that generation claimed that Sarah must have become pregnant from Avimelech. She had been married to Avrohom for so many years and did not have a child, yet shortly after being taken by Avimelech she became pregnant.

Rav Meir Shapiro zt’l (Imrei Da’as) noted that in a sense the cynic’s assessment was correct. For it was indeed on account of Avimelech that Sarah became pregnant. When Avimelech abducted Sarah, Hashem brought a terrible plague against him which affected his ability to bear children. He was only saved from the plague because Avrohom interceded on his behalf. The gemara (Bava Kamma 92a) states “If one davens on behalf of his friend, and he needs that same thing, he is answered first.” Therefore, because of the event involving Avimelech, in which Avrohom davened for Avimlech, he himself was answered and Sarah became pregnant, as Rashi explains in Bereishis 21:1.   

———————————————-

 “The first one emerged red, entirely like a hairy mantle, so they named him Esav.” (Bereishis 25:25)

Rashi notes that the name Eisav means “completely developed”.

Rav Chaim Kaufman zt’l (Mishchas Shemen) noted that people often think that it’s meritorious to be born with abilities and capabilities beyond the norm. In fact, the opposite is true! Success and growth in Torah are the result of toiling to overcome one’s shortcomings and build his character.

The mitzvah of B’ris Milah symbolizes this idea. A baby boy is born with a deficiency which needs to be corrected at the first opportunity. Milah raises the infant to a new level, for it is only then that he enters the covenant of Avrohom Avinu. A non-Jew cannot grasp this concept. The Medrash (Bereishis Rabbah 11:6) relates that a Philosopher asked Rabbi Hosheah if Hashem loves milah why doesn’t He create a baby already circumcised. Rabbi Hosheah replied that Hashem created a beautiful yet incomplete world; He left the rest to us.

Rav Kaufman relates that on one occasion Rav Yehuda Zev Segal zt’l, the Manchester Rosh Yeshiva was in Austria, and there were only nine men present for davening. One of the assembled jokingly suggested that the Rosh Yeshiva create a golem to be the tenth. The Manchester Rosh Yeshiva replied in a very serious tone that it is no great wisdom to create a thoughtless golem. The real challenge is to transform a golem into an intellectual, growing person.

One is not born into greatness; it is something one can only acquire through arduous dedication, passion, and commitment.


 ———————————————-

“Yaakov said “swear to me as this day”… he swore his birthright to Yaakov” (Bereishis 25:33)

Oznaim LaTorah notes that in order to consummate their exchange of the bechora for a bowl of lentils, Yaakov wanted Eisav to take an oath. But he was unsure what Eisav valued that he could base his oath upon. Eisav denied Hashem, so it would mean nothing to him to swear in Hashem’s Name. Eisav didn’t believe in Techyias Hameisim so it would be futile to ask him to swear based on his portion in Olam Haba.

Yaakov asked Eisav to swear based on this world – not the future, or even tomorrow, but on the present. “Swear to me as this day”, because that is what Eisav valued. Live in the moment; don’t think about tomorrow. “Eat drink and be merry for tomorrow we die!” Yaakov knew that Eisav wouldn’t lie if he swore based on the present moment, for that is what Eisav lived for and valued above all. 

———————————————-

 “And Eisav said, ‘Behold, I am going to die, so of what use to me is the birthright?’… Eisav disgraced the birthright.” (Bereishis 25:32-34)

The gemara (Bava Basra 16b) relates that the day Eisav spurned the birthright was the day Avrohom Avinu had died. Medrash (Bereishis Rabbah 63:11) states that Eisav asked Yaakov why he was cooking lentils. Yaakov replied that Avrohom had died, and he was cooking his father’s first meal as a mourner (seudas havra’ah). When Eisav heard that Avrohom had died he exclaimed “The attribute of judgment even effected that old man?! If so, there is no reward or resurrection of the dead.” That day Eisav committed five cardinal sins.

Why was Eisav so shaken by the death of Avrohom? Did he not know that every person, including the most righteous, eventually die? Furthermore, Hashem had foretold to Avrohom during the B’ris Bain Habsarim that he would die peacefully?

Bais Halevi explains that Eisav was well aware that Avrohom would die. But Eisav was also aware that Hashem had informed Avrohom that following his death, his progeny would descend into a dark exile. But, Hashem also told Avrohom (Bereishis 21:12) that “B’Yitzchok – in Yitzchok, your progeny will be called”. In other words, not all of Yitzchok’s children were deemed his progeny (see Nedarim 31a). Eisav reasoned that since the firstborn must be the chosen as the true progeny of Avrohom, it was only the firstborn’s descendants who would be subject to the prognosticated exile. Eisav felt if he could divest himself of the firstborn, then he and his descendants would be spared the imminent exile.

Eisav’s denial was for a purpose. He wanted to find reason to deny the veracity of reward and eternal consequences in order to assuage his conscience.

Only Yaakov’s descendants who bore the pain of exile merited the glory of redemption, and becoming the Chosen Nation. Eisav eternally forfeited that role.

———————————————-

Strivinghigher.com


[1] This series was originally written for and published in Hamodia.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share the Post:

Related Posts

28 May 2026

Parshas Naso 5772

14 May 2026

Parshas Bamidbar/Shavuos 5772

7 May 2026

Parshas Behar-Bechukosai 5772